Update: Severe mental illness and the risk of violence | Letters
A report from The Guardian — Opinion sets out the main available details, with claims kept attributed to their sources.
The Guardian — Opinion has covered a development concerning “Update: Severe mental illness and the risk of violence | Letters,” with the available account limited to the facts included in the supplied text.
A new willingness to acknowledge the risk that some people with severe mental illnesses may become violent is welcomed by Prof John F Morgan Your report of Sarah Hughes’s acknowledgment that mental health organisations have sometimes “softened the truth” about the relationship between serious mental illness and violence marks an important change in the public debate ( Mental health groups have ‘failed to acknowledge’ risk of violence, states Mind chief, 5 September ). The report also notes that There is some historical irony here. Mind grew from the National Association for Mental Health, an organisation in which psychiatrists and other mental health professionals played an important part. From the 1970s onwards, Mind increasingly defined itself as an independent campaigning organisation and, at times, a vigorous critic of psychiatric practice and authority.
Any statements, estimates or characterisations remain attributed to the people or organisations identified by the source. The excerpt alone does not provide a complete documentary record or necessarily include responses from every party involved.
Official statements or subsequent reporting may add context as the story develops. For now, this account is confined to information directly supported by the provided headline and excerpt.
Sources
- Severe mental illness and the risk of violence | Letters — The Guardian — Opinion
EGazette summarizes reporting from multiple sources; follow the links for the originals.
Related articles

Hutton and Haldane: Andy Burnham's 'public control' push on utilities is a minefield worth navigating
Writing in the Guardian, Will Hutton and Andy Haldane argue that full nationalisation isn't the only answer for firms like Thames Water, but that they could be run for public benefit.

Reader Responds: Youth Unemployment Requires Macroeconomic Solutions, Not Just Skills Training
A letter to The Guardian argues that increasing government spending, not apprenticeships alone, is needed to address youth unemployment.

Letter Writers Call for Simpler Access to UK Apprenticeship Schemes
Readers respond to reporting on low apprenticeship uptake, saying confusing systems deter young people from pursuing vocational training.

Readers Pay Tribute to Guardian Nature Columnist Phil Gates After Nearly 40 Years
Letter writers reflect on the influence of Phil Gates's country diary column following news of his final entry.

Letter Urges Americans in the UK to Vote as Control of Congress Hangs in the Balance
A reader argues that US citizens living abroad could influence the outcome of upcoming congressional elections.
The limits of Washington's security commitment to Saudi Arabia
A commentary argues Riyadh must recognize the risks of relying indefinitely on an external security guarantor as Gulf states weigh a more independent security posture.
Comments
Loading comments…